by Alex Danger Stewart
What: Six Nights Alone EP Review
Where: The band is from Rockford, IL. I’m writing this on a Compaq notebook.
Why? They asked us for coverage and I agreed because I support local music.
Keep Explaining: And that was a really long time ago because I forgot because I’m pretty flaky, then Chip reminded me today and I felt bad so I’m reviewing it now.
I usually have a pretty deliberate process when I review new music. Assuming that it’s a digital release (Vinyl has extra steps) I load it onto my Ipod and listen to it alone in my apartment (usually while eating a sandwich or Annie Chun Noodle Bowl™) not really thinking, just listening. Then I let my reactions percolate for a couple of days before finding a free evening and hoping on the train (usually the Brown Line cause it seems to take longer to get places), headphones in tow, to test out the dichotomy between listening to it in a noisy anonymous environment and also doing so in the near solitude of walking through a residential neighborhood in Lincoln Park or Ravenswood. Then I often come home and write the first couple hundred words of the review before getting distracted and doing other things (usually sleeping). Then, about a week later, I finally force myself to sit down and finish it and I usually play the key songs again while writing about them.
This review is pretty much ignoring those methods.
Why?
Well, for a couple of reasons. First, because the band solicited coverage from Sock Monkey Sound. Don’t get me wrong, I love it when bands give me free music in exchange for press. It’s happened like 3 times so far and it makes me feel like a professional. But I do have some integrity and I’m pretty unlikely to have any built in sentimentality for a band that I’ve never heard of just because they’re local so I’m not as motivated to care about being super thorough, or about holding back some of the harsher criticisms I might think up. Plus I think all of these songs are on the band’s Myspace page (how am I supposed to feel elitist if everyone can hear them for free?). The second reason is that I’m coming into this review with somewhat low expectations.
Why?
There are, once again, a couple of reasons. One of the band members has a somewhat checkered history and I take a little bit of issue with the way they are promoting themselves. Singer/guitarist Aaron Whalen used to be in Killing Abraham (http://www.myspace.com/killingabraham) which was a band for which I held an unbridled hatred. I so vehemently disliked them that (like 4 years after the last time I even had the displeasure of seeing them play) I made an unflattering reference to one of their shitty songs in the Special Thanks section of my band Boys Like Jason’s (insert shameless plug (http://boyslikejason.bandcamp.com/) )self released debut EP last year. That’s quite petty, but I can’t help it. They were that bad. You, the reader, have to ask, “Isn’t that unfair to prejudge a band based on one member’s past creative efforts?” No because he is listing himself as a former member of Killing Abraham on Six Nights Alone’s Myspace page so he’s actively asking us to draw comparisons to those past efforts. That leads to my second cause for some suspicion that this band might suck. Their Myspace page lists their influences as “Waylon Jennings, Willie Nelson, Johnny Cash, and people who aren’t afraid to do something different.” Waylon, Willy, and Johnny are ALWAYS the influence that bands list when they want to cover up the fact that their main influence is Uncle Tupelo/Son Volt’s first album and that at least 2 members really enjoy the Johnny Cash American releases. Bands who list those influences never ever ever sound anything like Waylon, Willy, or Johnny.
Here’s why this band might not suck, though: I love Uncle Tupelo and SNA has a ton of shows booked over the summer in diverse venues across the Midwest and Eastern part of the country. Plus they have an old guy playing pedal steel. I fucking love pedal steel guitar and old guys are usually really good steel players. So……….After too long of a prologue, I’ve sat down with two beers (beer makes me less discerning) and it’s time to listen to/write about the songs.
This band totally sounds like Uncle Tupelo’s first two releases. I fucking knew it! “Don’t Care,” could easily have been a demo that didn’t make the cut from the No Depression sessions. Whalen’s voice is clearly not as good as Jay Farrar’s but that’s a totally unreasonable thing to criticize. Apart from a very misplaced breakdown at 2:30, I’m totally jamming to this. The pedal steel is good enough to almost carry the end of the song through some rough patches. Good job Mark Oberfoell.
Every Alt Country band has a song about drinking your life away that rings slightly untrue (mostly because Alt Country band members are usually too young to have developed a really strong drinking problem). “Ode to Zeus,” is that song for Six Nights Alone. Pushed along by a nice train beat, this has the makings of a pretty solid song along. I’m noticing a trend though. At about the halfway point of every song, they divert from the loud country style that was totally working and start sticking in pop punk elements. This does not work. I wish they would stop.
“Shout! Wont Take Out Makers,” has my favorite lyric so far. “Well I spent two weeks sober and I didn’t even know her. Help me drown my pain away.” That’s really good. The title is actually pretty clever, referring to the detergent’s inability to wash out stains from my favorite bourbon. This song is working for me.
I don’t have much to say about, “Stealin Your Heart.” This song mostly works except, once again, there’s a damn half time break down 2 ½ minutes into the song. Stop that!
Finally, a song in 12/8. “Sunset Blvd,” brings some much needed head bobbing and a bit of doom. Mark Oberfoell is fucking owning this song with his pedal steel. And there are no break downs! I might listen to this song again just for the hell of it.
Complaints that I have overall: The production feels too contemporary for such a bartastic band. I don’t feel like they’re playing together in a smelly, beer stained room, which is always the aesthetic that you want when a band mixes loud and twang. In a similar vein, the meter is way too straight. I’d like to hear drummer Paul Metz loosen up and let things swing a little. Also I really wanted a guitar solo somewhere in the EP. If they had replaced every breakdown with a twangy solo, I’d be a happy man.
Final Verdict: I don’t know that I enjoyed these songs enough to recommend them outright, but if you walk into a bar and find this band playing, stick around for a little while. There are some definite positive points in every song. The best parts were those that ignored the band’s pop punk instincts. That should be obvious, though.
Check out Six Nights Alone at http://www.myspace.com/6nightsalone




Aaron Whalen
04/14/2010
thanks guys. not bad i guess. we did all five songs in ten hours in the studio. full length is in the works for this summer when we get some $ saved up to have plenty of time in the studio.
Taylor
04/14/2010
Wow! So quick to judge. What do you do musically?
@chipcopeland
04/14/2010
I think he did a pretty decent job of explaining him self and his thoughts . While Danger obviously doesn't care for Killing Abraham, which to some might come of a bit harsh (it did me) , but I think he had an overall positive review of 6 Nights Alone. Taylor, he does leave a link to his own project in the piece. Feel free to review his work in the comments here, I'm sure he won't mind.
Criticism, in my opinion, is always good as long as it's constructive and people can always change their mind down the road if they like. Jim DeRogatis hated Weezer's seminal album Pinkerton, only to recant his initial assessment years later.
GiaLovesPoppies
04/15/2010
bout time ''the old guy'' got some props!
sending love, marco…xoxo g.
Danger
04/15/2010
Taylor, I would hardly call 1200 words a quick judgment. I do agree that my lingering dislike of Killing Abraham was somewhat unfair but this release was different and positive enough for the band to stand on its own and my final judgement reflected that. I consider this review to be more positive than negative.
What I do musically has no bearing on my ability to criticize or praise the works of others. If I thought my best way to contribute to the musical community was through playing, I would be doing so as a primary activity instead of a hobby. As I see it, my expertise lies more in listening to/experiencing music and relaying my reaction to others. Negative criticisms that I make are not based in the idea that I could do better (unless I actually say so, which I don't recall doing so far) but in the idea that others can/have done better, or that the artists did not accomplish the goals of their creation.
There's a link in the review but I'll save you some time and direct you towards my music herehttp://boyslikejason.bandcamp.com/ . Feel free to review it in the comments or elsewhere. It's all available for free download if you end up liking anything.
Chip, Thanks for comparing me to Jim DeRogatis. I'm going to pretend that you think our writing is of equal quality. Or that I'm better, cause I liked Pinketron the first time around.
Danger
04/15/2010
Taylor, I would hardly call 1200 words a quick judgment. I do agree that my lingering dislike of Killing Abraham was somewhat unfair but this release was different and positive enough for the band to stand on its own and my final judgement reflected that. I consider this review to be more positive than negative.
What I do musically has no bearing on my ability to criticize or praise the works of others. If I thought my best way to contribute to the musical community was through playing, I would be doing so as a primary activity instead of a hobby. As I see it, my expertise lies more in listening to/experiencing music and relaying my reaction to others. Negative criticisms that I make are not based in the idea that I could do better (unless I actually say so, which I don't recall doing so far) but in the idea that others can/have done better, or that the artists did not accomplish the goals of their creation.
There's a link in the review but I'll save you some time and direct you towards my music herehttp://boyslikejason.bandcamp.com/ . Feel free to review it in the comments or elsewhere. It's all available for free download if you end up liking anything.
Chip, Thanks for comparing me to Jim DeRogatis. I'm going to pretend that you think our writing is of equal quality. Or that I'm better, cause I liked Pinketron the first time around.
chipcopeland
04/15/2010
No, problem dude. You're the NEW DeRogatis. Maybe Rockford's answer to DeRogatis (even though you live in Chicago).
Gia, old guys playing pedal steel is what makes the world turn. If we didn't have those the earth would sin into the sun.
Aaron Whalen
04/15/2010
I didnt expect much out of our first cd anyways, other than helping with booking shows as you can see by our schedule. this isnt going to detour us in anyway of developing a punk country sound. I honestly have never listened to Uncle Tupelo, but i surely will check them out. I agree with abandoning our past music experiences, and this is a completely new project for all of us and a departure from most of our past bands. In the same respect though I guess it holds true that you're always seventeen in your home town.
chipcopeland
04/15/2010
Aaron, I moved to get away from the 17 year old high school plague.
Dude, Uncle Tupelo sprouted 2 of the greatest alt-country bands ever – Son Volt and Wilco. Essential listening in my opinion.
Denny Garcia
04/16/2010
The 1st time I heard 6 nites alone I felt like a sixty year old teenager lookin' for nookie..I've jammed with Aaron's dad and Mark O. The "old guy" steel player fills in more cool holes than are in the Albert hall..Actually Mark was exactly what those fellers needed to spark the band… Makes me want to play some hot rod fiddle on occasion…shredding music is not my thing ..there is plenty of music police out there to take care of that..I usually just leave if I don't like something…Six Nites Alone is doin' just fine and then some…I got to fix Aaron's broken neck on his Les Paul…Play on brothers..Denny Garcia..along the Mississippi…
Murasshole
07/26/2010
I have a few comments… at first when Aaron said the had never heard SunVolt or UT .. I figured he was flat out lying.. then I looked at the picture of their gear… I believe him.. there is no way someone can own No Depression or Trace and also own racked up guitar gear (a racked Marshall head? really?) . That being said here are my suggestions Aaron and other dudes.
Go out and buy these records:
Uncle Tupelo- Entire Catalog
Son Volt – Trace
WIlco – AM and Being There
Just for fun pick up the Felice Brothers
Next let's talk gear…
the Paul is fine I suppose
sell the Marshall, the Mesa or whatever the hell the diamond tread amp thing is, any thing with rack mounts, and that PRS.. what is that an SE?
go buy:
a tube screamer (or some boutique version of a tube screamer) each
one of you get a Fender Deluxe one get a VOX AC 15… some get a F)(*&ing Tele.. and throw away your wah pedals and maybe get a tremelo ( I like the green Boss one).
The pedal guy kicks ass.